Item Quality:
While Brick Hills Items look unpolished, imo Polytoria items either look TOO polished or worse than any BH item, so Brick Hill wins this one

Moderation:
While I don't like that you can't swear on Polytoria, I acknowledge sandboxes are for kids. BH mods are also blind, so Polytoria wins this one (1/?)

Playerbase:
(this doesnt count discord) Polytoria OT is much nicer than BH OT, so Polytoria wins this one

Avatars:
Polytoria avatars imo look too polished, to the point i don't like it, BH wins this one (2/?)

Website design:
Polytoria wins

Website quality:
BH wins (3/?)

Amount of players:
While Brick Hill has a lot of accounts registered, it's mostly alt accounts/inactive people/terminated accounts, and consists mostly of KonekoKitten 2019ers and outage 2021ers, Polytoria has less players but I rarely see a terminated account or a bigot here, so Polytoria wins even though Brick Hill has more players.

Economy:
Straight up horrible on Polytoria (to the point an eco reset has to happen), BH wins

P.S. Please do not attack me since it's just my opinion (4/4)

BH is 13+ while polytoria is <13 so polytoria automatically wins

you forgot game client comparison

poly client wins easily, thanks for reminding me

Brick Hill is full of edgy teenagers, which is ironic coming from me considering I am BOS, but still

Brick Hill's client is bad overall, that combined with no way of automatically hosting games without paying for a bad server to host the game on.

cant that have a negative outtake due to some people in our society